Welcome to the Heinemann Professional Development Professional Learning Community (PLC) series. Each month, we'll share a post designed to provoke thinking and discussion through a simple framework, incorporating mini-collections of linked content.
Use these as learning modules during your professional development time, whether in a team, a PLC, or on your own!
Welcome to the Heinemann Professional Development Professional Learning Community (PLC) series. Each month, we'll share a post designed to provoke thinking and discussion through a simple framework, incorporating mini-collections of linked content.
Use these as learning modules during your professional development time, whether in a team, a PLC, or on your own!
♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
by Jaclyn Karabinas
Connect
Find a moment with your thoughts to visualize a time where you:
-
surprised yourself at how you responded (or didn’t) to something.
-
were in a conversation or situation where you purposefully hid elements of your identity.
-
stopped or redirected a challenging conversation because you didn’t feel you had the capacity or language to make it productive.
Consider
In our last PLC series post, we explored the idea that responding to students based on stereotypes acts as an enemy to equity. Today, we explore how introspection and the consistent, ongoing work of unpacking the layers of our own identities assists us with being better teachers.
Keep our Guiding Questions in mind: Why is it crucial that educators do identity work themselves? How can we use identity work to impact pedagogy, improve relationships and ultimately, teaching and learning?
Educate
To ground your thinking as we begin, listen to this podcast (transcript also available) with Cohort 3 Heinemann Fellow Minjung Pai and two educators she admires and learns from frequently.
In it, Min describes a moment that her thinking about identity exploration shifted:
“...just beginning my teaching, I felt like I had to be "professional." So, if I'm professional, I'm not their friend, I'm their teacher. I shouldn't share my entire self and to me, that was a real contrast to what I wanted my students to do, because I wanted my students to bring their full selves in because only when they do that can they really access learning and take risks to grow and challenge themselves. So that's why for me, that personal identity work is so important to teachers because if I don't understand myself, how can I teach my students to understand themselves?”
It is 40 minutes long, so plan ahead for fitting this into that car ride (or split between two shorter ones), long run, or evening reading time; it is a valuable 40 minutes for you to immerse yourself in their stories about how personal identity work has impacted their lives as people and educators.
As you listen or read, jot down phrases or lines that really hit your heart and mind (TIP: the transcript is helpful for this to capture the exact words).
Reflect
Review the lines you lifted. Choose one to use as a jumping-off point for a quick write that will deepen your thinking as you move forward with the next steps. Allow yourself 5-7 minutes to write where this line takes you (a wonderful strategy from Linda Rief). Just write. Don’t think too much.
Practice
In her book Upstanders, coauthored with Smokey Daniels, and Being the Change, Sara Ahmed shares thinking and lessons surrounding the practice of creating identity webs with students and using them throughout the year as a part of ongoing learning experience. An identity web is what it sounds like—a web that shows the elements and layers that describe you, the characteristics that make you you.
As we are focusing on doing this work ourselves before we bring it to students, grab a notebook and pen and make your own identity web. Watch this video with Sara to hear about why she takes the time to “hold the mirror up” to understand what this is like for kids.
Extend
Look closely at your web and write a list of questions that come to mind as you examine what is on it, what isn’t, and how it might affect what you bring to your classroom. In the podcast, Jason David shares some questions that he explores for identity work, which may be a helpful place to begin:
-
Who am I and why does it matter?
-
How do I show up in the world?
-
What are my values?
-
How does my identity web illuminate my worldview?
Refine
This piece by Cohort 2 Heinemann Fellow, Anna Osborn, provides another opportunity to learn about the intersection of identity and learning.
She writes:
“I mistakenly thought the key for my students and myself was to eschew the identities that cause us discomfort, to avoid the deficit labels others put upon us. I now realize I must make space in our classroom to share our vulnerabilities so that we can move beyond the shame of those labels, ultimately allowing us to reclaim our identities as part of who we are and can become.”
Act
Over the next couple weeks, keep your identity web in the back of your mind and take notice of how elements of your identity seem to shape how you participate in conversations, design learning experiences or the environment in your classroom, respond to news, or specific students.
Make the commitment (preferably alongside colleagues) to continue learning about identity work through self-observation, so you can begin to understand not only how to do this with students, but understand how they are individuals weaving their own identity webs, webs they bring to school each day.
Commit to ongoing learning to strive towards answering our questions: Why is it crucial that educators do identity work themselves? How can we use identity work to impact pedagogy, improve relationships and ultimately, teaching and learning?
Many thanks to cohort 3 Heinemann Fellow Minjung Pai for the inspiration to the work in this learning module.
For Further Reading:
- PLC Series November 2018: Stereotypes as an Enemy of Equity
- PLC Series October 2018: Listening to Students as a Priority
