Instructional coaching cycles are among the most effective ways to support teacher growth and improve student outcomes. Yet for many educators, especially those new to the process, the idea of being coached can feel unfamiliar and even uncomfortable. But when coaching is implemented with intention, it offers a collaborative, sustainable way to refine instruction and build teacher capacity over time.
This guide walks through the basic structure of an instructional coaching cycle and shares insights from experienced coaches who have seen the impact of effective coaching. Whether you're an early-career teacher or a school leader building a coaching program, you’ll come away with a clearer understanding of how and why coaching cycles work.
Understanding Instructional Coaching
Unlike one-off workshops or top-down evaluations, instructional coaching is grounded in partnership. A coach and a teacher work together, identifying goals, trying new strategies, and reflecting on what’s working for students.
As described by the Regional Educational Laboratory (REL) Pacific, effective instructional coaching is ongoing, collaborative, and focused on improving both pedagogy and content delivery. It’s built on mutual respect, trust, and a shared commitment to student learning.
Michelle White, an instructional coach, sees relationship-building as foundational to coaching. For her, the process begins with understanding the teacher and creating a safe space where growth can happen without fear of judgment. The goal of coaching is not to “fix” anything, but to support teachers in helping them as they grow and develop new skills.
The Flow of an Instructional Coaching Cycle
While terminology and timing may differ across schools, most coaching cycles follow a similar structure that includes three main stages: Identify, Learn, and Improve.
1) Identify
The coaching process begins with clarity. Coaches help teachers take a close look at their current practice, sometimes through live classroom observation or on video, and define a clear goal centered on student impact. The focus might be improving engagement during discussions or supporting more effective transitions. What matters is that the goal is meaningful to the teacher’s needs.
Kathleen Talbot, an instructional coach, emphasizes the importance of starting from the teacher’s context. Coaches don’t come in with a pre-set agenda for a teacher, they collaborate to figure out what matters most and where small shifts could make a big difference.
2) Learn
Once a goal is in place, the coach supports the teacher in exploring strategies to address it. This might involve modeling a technique, co-teaching a lesson, or sharing a resource that aligns with the teacher’s needs. Notably, the learning is active. The teacher isn’t being “trained,” instead they’re trying out new methods, reflecting on how they land, and adapting along the way.
Coaches often demonstrate practices in small, manageable ways. A routine like Think-Pair-Share might be introduced through a short modeling session, followed by time to debrief. The point isn’t perfection, it’s progress. If a strategy doesn’t work the first time, coach and teacher regroup, reflect, and adjust.
3) Improve
In the last stage of the cycle, the teacher implements the new strategies more fully. The coach helps gather data—not just test scores, but patterns in student engagement, participation, or confidence. Together, they reflect on the results, talk through what worked and what didn’t, and identify next steps.
Christina Lastoria, an instructional coach, notes that this is often the turning point. Once teachers see a tangible impact on students, even from just a small change, they feel energized and more confident to keep going.
Why Trust Matters in Effective Coaching
While the coaching process is structured, its success often depends on something less tangible: trust. Teachers are more willing to take risks, reflect honestly, and try something new when they feel safe and supported. Coaches build that trust by listening deeply, being clear about what’s confidential, and collaborating rather than directing.
Coaches build trust by making it a priority to explain early on what information will be shared with administrators during the process and what remains private between the coach and teacher. That transparency builds a strong foundation. Talbot notes that when teachers have a voice in how their growth is documented, by co-writing notes or setting goals collaboratively, they feel a greater sense of ownership and agency.
Instructional Coaching That Fits Teachers’ Needs
One of the most common constraints teachers face is simply having time. And coaching can feel like one more thing added to a very full plate. But effective coaches help make sure that the process aligns to real needs and doesn’t burden teachers.
Good coaching connects to what teachers are already working on. It supports—not replaces—the instruction already happening. When aligned with existing goals, coaching becomes part of the daily rhythm rather than an extra burden. As White puts it, it’s not about adding more. It’s about enhancing what’s already there.
The Role of Mindset in Effective Coaching
What makes a teacher “coachable” isn’t experience or expertise, it’s mindset. The most successful coaching relationships happen when teachers are open to feedback and willing to reflect, even if they don’t have all the answers.
Lastoria says being coachable just means being willing to say, “I’d like to be better at this.” That willingness to learn and grow is the heart of the coaching process.
Examples of Effective Coaching in Action
The power of coaching comes through in the stories educators share. In one case, Lastoria supported a reading intervention teacher who started the year with a caseload of more than 90 students. Through intentional goal setting and differentiated instruction, that number dropped to 20 by year’s end. The shift wasn’t due to dramatic staffing changes, it was the result of focused, supported adjustments over time.
In another school, White worked with a team of teachers to introduce consistent routines for discussion and student engagement. Simple practices like Think-Pair-Share led to more active participation and deeper academic conversations, without changing the curriculum or adding new programs.
These kinds of changes aren’t flashy, but they’re powerful. And they’re sustainable because they’re built on real collaboration and meaningful feedback.
Advice for Getting Started in a Coaching Cycle
When starting a new coaching cycle, coaches Lastoria, Talbot, and White offered this guidance:
- Start with Curiosity: A teacher doesn’t need all the answers. A desire to learn is more than enough.
- Focus on Students: Coaching is about helping the teacher, so they can better help their students succeed.
- Stay Open: Reflection and feedback are tools for growth, not judgment.
Coaching cycles aren’t about being perfect. They’re about making small, intentional moves that lead to lasting change.
***
Looking for Coaching Support?
Heinemann offers professional learning designed to meet educators where they are. Whether you're beginning your first coaching cycle or looking to deepen your school’s coaching culture, we can help.
Explore coaching and more professional learning opportunities provided by Heinemann.
Explore Heinemann’s professional learning services.
